The Weekly Newspaper serving the citizens of Morenci, Mich., Fayette, Ohio, and surrounding areas.

  • Snow.2
    FIRST SNOW—Heavy, wet flakes piled deep on tree branches—and windshields—as the area received its first significant snowfall of the season. “Usually it begins with a dusting or two,” said George Isobar, Morenci’s observer for the National Weather Service, “but this time it came with a vengeance.” By the end of the day Saturday, a little over four inches of snow was on the ground. Now comes the thaw with temperatures in the 40s and 50s for three days.
  • Front.sculpt
    SKEWERS, gumdrops, and marshmallows are all that’s needed to create interesting shapes and designs for Layla McDowell Saturday at Stair District Library’s “Sculptamania!” Open House. The program featuring design games and materials is one part of a larger project funded by a $7,500 Curiosity Creates grant from Disney and the American Library Association. Additional photos are on page 7.
    Morenci marching band members took to the field Friday night dressed for Halloween during the Bulldog’s first playoff game. Morenci fans had a bit of a scare until the fourth quarter when the Bulldogs scored 30 points to leave Lenawee Christian School behind. Whiteford visits Morenci this Friday for the district championship game. From the left is Clayton Borton, Morgan Merillat and James O’Brien.
    DNA PUZZLE—Mitchell Storrs and Wyatt Mohr tackle a puzzle representing the structure of DNA. There’s only one correct way for all the pieces to fit. It’s one of the new materials that can be used in both biology and chemistry classes, said teacher Loretta Cox.
  • Front.tar.wide
    A TRAFFIC control worker stands in the middle of Morenci’s Main Street Tuesday morning, waiting for the next flow of vehicles to be let through from the west. The dusty gravel surface was sealed with a layer of tar, leaving only the application of paint for new striping. The project was completed in conjunction with county road commission work west of Morenci.
  • Front.pull
    JUNIORS Jazmin Smith and Trevor Corkle struggle against a team from the sophomore class Friday during the annual tug of war at the Homecoming Games pep rally. Even the seniors struggled against the sophomores who won the competition. At the main course of the day, the Bulldog football team struggled against Whiteford in a homecoming loss.
    YOUNG soccer players surived a chilly morning Saturday in Morenci’s PTO league. From the left is Emma Cordts, Wayne Corser, Carter and Levi Seitz, Briella York and Drew Joughin. Two more weeks of soccer remain for this season.
  • Front.ropes
    BOWEN BAUMGARTNER of Morenci makes his way across a rope bridge constructed by the Tecumseh Boy Scout troop Sunday at Lake Hudson Recreation Area. The bridge was one of many challenges, displays and games set up for the annual Youth Jamboree by the Michigan DNR. Additional photos on are the back page of this week’s Observer.
  • Front.homecoming Court
    One of four senior candidates will be crowned the fall homecoming queen during half-time of this week’s Morenci-Whiteford football game. In the back row (left to right) is exchange student Kinga Vidor (her escort will be Caylob Alcock), seniors Alli VanBrandt (escorted by Sam Cool), Larissa Elliott (escorted by Clayton Borton), Samantha Wright (escorted by JJ Elarton) and Justis McCowan (escorted by Austin Gilson), and exchange student Rebecca Rosenberger (escorted by Garrett Smith). Front row freshman court member Allie Kaiser (escorted by Anthony Thomas), sophomore Marlee Blaker (escorted by Nate Elarton) and junior Cheyenne Stone (escorted by Dominick Sell).
  • Front.park.lights
    GETTING READY—Jerad Gleckler pounds nails to secure a string of holiday lights on the side of the Wakefield Park concession stand while other members of the Volunteer Club and others hold them in place. The volunteers showed up Sunday afternoon to string lights at the park. The decorating project will continue this Sunday. Denise Walsh is in charge of the effort this year.
  • Front.homecoming Court
  • Cheer
  • Front.park.lights
  • Front.pull
  • Front.ropes
  • Front.sculpt
  • Front.tar.wide
  • Front.toss
  • Front.walk Across

Opinions mixed on industrial wind farms 2012.06.20

Written by David Green.


No one can accuse Lori Glisson of being a NIMBY. She’s not someone who can tolerate wind turbines as long as they’re “Not In My Back Yard.”

She’s leading the effort to alter Seneca Township’s new wind energy ordinance even though there won’t be a turbine in her back yard.

The Glissons live in the section of Seneca Township that’s zoned residential and wind turbines are off limits in that area.

Glisson said she’s followed wind energy developments for 10 years and she’s taken an interest in the ill health effects that many people report. Wind development companies tend to dismiss complaints, but the reports of problems continue as wind farms increase in number.

Glisson said she wasn’t aware that the Seneca Township planning commission was working on wind power regulations until she read in the Observer that an ordinance was being patterned after the one in Palmyra Township—an ordinance that’s much less restrictive than Riga Township’s.

She believes Seneca’s ordinance was rushed into place without addressing the concerns she presented to the board. After the township board approved the ordinance in March, Glisson says she was left with no option other than to seek a referendum that would allow all township residents to decide if the new law sufficiently protects citizens.

She had no trouble obtaining enough signatures for the referendum vote and now she’s working to explain wind farm operations to people before the Aug. 7 vote.

Glisson has scheduled an informational meeting at 7 p.m. June 27 at the Morenci American Legion. Representatives of the Interstate Informed Citizens Coalition (IICC) will attend the meeting. The group’s goal is to raise public awareness of health and safety issues related to industrial wind turbines.

“I don’t have a problem with turbines if they’re not impacting people,” Glisson said, but she thinks much greater protection is needed for non-participating residents—those who aren’t willing to sign a lease for the construction of a turbine.

The Seneca ordinance allows a turbine to be erected a distance of three times its height from a non-participating resident’s house. The sound is limited to 45 decibels, as measured at a resident’s home.

People’s reactions to living near an industrial turbine are mixed and very subjective. Many people aren’t bothered by them at all; others complain about the noise—from the whooshing of the blades, from occasional mechanical noises when the turbine heads are turned, and from a low-frequency noise that’s felt by some individuals, as when a car stereo with a loud base drives by.

Many people are also bothered by rapidly moving shadows (known as shadow flicker) from turbine blades during a certain part of the day.

In Glisson’s view, if turbines can’t be placed in Seneca Township in a way that avoids these problems, then they don’t belong there.

Moving north

Last November Riga Township residents voted nearly two to one to uphold an ordinance that wind farm developers said effectively banned them from erecting turbines in the township. Setback requirements and noise limits were more restrictive than developers could tolerate for efficient operation.

A company known as Blissfield Wind Energy canceled its plans to develop a wind farm in the Riga/Palmyra area and instead turned its interest north toward Gratiot and Ionia counties.

Plans were already underway for a wind energy facility on farmland situated between Alma and Saginaw, in Gratiot County. In March of this year, 133 wind turbines went on-line to create what is currently Michigan’s largest wind farm.

The turbines measure 463 feet from the ground to the tip of the blade and cost an average of $3.3 million each—made possible with large federal subsidies. The project spans about 30,000 acres of farmland that involves portions of four townships.

Breckinridge farmer Kent Humm, who is also a Bethany Township board trustee, said collaboration between the townships was underway before wind development was on the horizon.

It made sense for the townships to continue working together for the development of a wind energy ordinance, Humm said, and eventually a public hearing was scheduled to involve residents from all four areas.

Each group made sure that any subdivision areas were zoned residential to keep turbines at a distance.

“Originally there were to be no more than four turbines per section [square mile],” Humm said. Now that they’re erected, the majority of the property involved has no more than one or two per section.

Humm has four turbines on his farms that total 800 acres. Most of the turbines are placed off to the edge of farmland to minimize interferences with crops.

Participating land owners received an initial $1,000 payment. Developers suggested the money could be used for legal fees if participants wanted an attorney to examine the contracts.

Property owners now receive $6.23 annually for every acre in the lease, even though a turbine takes up a small portion of a field.

Any property owner is invited to join in—not just farmers with large acreage. 

“At least they’re involved,” Humm said. “Everyone is getting treated the same.”

Everyone involved will share in a pool of money equal to four percent of the developer’s gross profits. Developers suggested this could be about $65 an acre. For Humm, that includes 25 acres of woods.

Developers figure a turbine takes up about three acres and they pay $300 per acre at each turbine location. Humm said the turbine near his house actually took about three-fourths of an acre out of production, and there’s nothing he could grow that would bring in as much cash as what he’s getting from turbine leases.

Humm admits there are pros and cons to the issue. 

“Is it going to solve our electrical needs?” he asked.

Of course not, but it will contribute toward meeting the always increasing demand for power.

And, yes, they make noise, but nothing that troubles his family. 

“You get accustomed to it,” Humm said, just like people who live near a railroad or some other source of sound.

He knows that the shadow flicker bothers some people, but it doesn’t last long when it occurs—unlike the ceiling fans in his house that produce a flicker as long as they’re running.

There are always some people who will complain, Humm said, but that number appears to be small in his area. By and large, he thinks area residents are pleased to be part of the state’s largest wind energy facility.

He likes the appearance of them and enjoys watching them spin.

That’s not the case for many people including Lori Glisson.

“The more I research them, the less I like them,” she said, “and the more determined I get.”

The success or failure of her campaign to alter the existing ordinance—to make changes she believes will better protect the citizens of Seneca Township—won’t be known until after the Aug. 7 vote.

Weekly newspaper serving SE Michigan and NW Ohio - State Line Observer ©2006-2015