Vreba-Hoff, DEQ reach settlement 6.13.07

Written by David Green.

By DAVID GREEN

A new waste treatment system, another financial penalty, limits on herd growth, enhanced reporting requirements, eventual closure of the Packard Road satellite lagoon, and the threat of new fines for unlawful discharges—those are among the points listed in a 62-page interim order announced June 6 in a Lansing circuit court.

The Michigan Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) and Vreba-Hoff Dairy signed a settlement agreement June 6 to end legal action against dairy owners that began in January.

As in past settlements, accepting the document “does not constitute an admission by Vreba-Hoff that the law has been violated.” The DEQ has issued citations for discharges on numerous occasions since the first of two farms opened south of Hudson in 1998.

Vreba-Hoff will pay $180,000 in fines to the State of Michigan for violations and enforcement costs and must have a new waste treatment system in operation by Sept. 15. The new EarthMentor system—expected to cost in excess of $2 million—is described below.

Existing manure lagoons will be converted for use in the new six-step treatment system and additional cells will be constructed. A 30 million gallon, clay-lined treatment cell is under construction at the Vreba-Hoff II farm on U.S.-127 and a 23 million gallon cell is being built at Vreba-Hoff I on Dillon Highway.

Smaller treatment cells and manure processing buildings will also be constructed.

If the dairy company fails to treat manure as specified in the settlement, manure must be removed from the farm or the number of cows must be reduced.

Unlawful discharges will bring fines of up to $10,000 a day, depending on the nature of the discharge.

The satellite lagoon constructed early this year on Packard Road can be used for manure storage either for an additional 32 months or until all manure in the lagoon is treated via the new EarthMentor system.

In January, the DEQ sought a herd reduction of 40 percent, but through a mediation process, the population of approximately 6,530 cows was to be reduced to 6,266. This figure was reached before the settlement was announced, according Vreba-Hoff attorney Jack Van Kley.

When the Earth Mentor system is in operation, the dairy will be able to increase herd size to 6,466. When the primary treatment cell reaches operational capacity and is ready to discharge into the second treatment cell, the herd may be increased by no more than 100 cows a month until a maximum of 7,266 is reached.

Vreba-Hoff must refrain from building any new structures for animals for 10 years.

The dairy is faced with a several guidelines, such as informing the DEQ before land application, observing setbacks along streams, incorporating manure into the soil on the day it is applied, and regulating the amount of untreated manure in storage.

Michigan attorney general Mike Cox stated in a DEQ press release that, “Mega-farms require great regulatory scrutiny because they have the potential to severely impact the environment. The enforcement action taken was a necessary step to compel compliance with our environmental laws and again demonstrates my commitment to preserve and protect our natural resources.”

Tom Menke, a consultant with a new environmental management company, said, “Vreba-Hoff is pleased that all issues have been resolved, and is looking forward to proceeding with exciting new advances in technology.”

Details:

A settlement reached last week with the Michigan DEQ calls for installation of a new treatment system incorporating elements of a typical municipal system, along with enhancements to meet the needs of the dairy. The system is known as the EarthMentor Natural Nutrient Reclamation and Treatment System.

The six-step process is more extensive than many municipal systems, said Vreba-Hoff attorney Jack Van Kley, and it’s new for dairies to use this approach.

1. The first step, Van Kley said, is to install sand separation units at both farms to remove sand from manure. The sand is used as bedding in the barns.

The cyclone sand separation system creates a vortex inside a tank, explained Mark Knoblauch of Morenci, who serves as an environmental consultant to Vreba-Hoff. Knoblauch operated the City of Hudson’s wastewater treatment system for many years.

Between 75 and 80 percent of the sand will settle out, Knoblauch said, which will be composted to kill off pathogens.

2. Manure is then run through a system to begin separating solids from liquids. The solids could be run through the existing press system that Knoblauch has made operational or they could be composted without the press system.  Van Kley said the press system will be shut down when the new one is operational. After composting, the solids will be applied on fields.

3. Liquids are directed into the first settling basis for additional separation. Pumps will be used to remove solids.

4. Liquids then move on to a second settling basin to continue the settling process. Existing storage lagoons will be used in the process along with some new construction.

“You’re getting water with less and less manure in it,” Knoblauch said.

5. Anaerobic treatment begins in step 5, incorporating a lagoon holding up to 40 million gallons. The anaerobic process is just like Morenci’s wastewater system, Knoblauch said, where the lack of oxygen kills off pathogens over time.

The liquid will be held here for six months, he said, with additional settling occurring.

6. A holding cell will store the liquid before it’s used for irrigation.

“By the time it makes it to step six, it’s probably clean enough,” Van Kley said, although additional treatment will continue there.

It’s tested technology, Knoblauch said, although it’s not tested on cow manure. While municipal systems discharge into a river, liquid from the Vreba-Hoff system will only be used for field application.

  • Front.nok Hok
    GAMES DAY—Finn Molitierno (right) celebrates a goal during a game of Nok Hockey with his sister, Kyla. The two tried out a variety of games Saturday at Stair District Library’s annual International Games Day event. One of the activities featured a sort of scavenger hunt in which participants had to locate facts presented in the Smithsonian Hometown Teams exhibit. The traveling show left Morenci’s library Tuesday, wrapping up a series of programs that began Oct. 2. Additional photos are on page 7.
  • Station.2
    STRANGE STUFF—Morenci Elementary School students learn that blue isn’t really blue when seen through the right color of lens. Volunteer April Pike presents the lesson to students at one of the many stations brought to the school by the COSI science center. The theme of this year’s visit was the solar system.
  • Front.leaves
    MAPLE leaves show their fall colors in a puddle at Morenci’s Riverside Natural Area. “This was a great year for colors,” said local weather watcher George Isobar. Chilly mornings will give way to seasonable fall temperatures for the next two weeks.
  • Front.band
    MORENCI Marching Band member Brittany Dennis keeps the beat Friday during the half-time show of the Morenci/Pittsford football game. Color guard member Jordan Cordts is at the left. The band performed this season under the direction of Doyle Rodenbeck who served as Morenci’s band director in the 1970s. He’s serving as a substitute during a family leave.
  • Front.poles
    MOVING EAST—Utility workers continue their slow progress east along U.S. 20 south of Morenci. New electrical poles are put in place before wiring is moved into place.
  • Front.cowboy
    A PERFORMER named Biligbaatar, a member of the AnDa Union troupe from Inner Mongolia, dances at Stair District Library last week during a visit to the Midwest. The nine-member group blends a variety of traditions from Inner and Outer Mongolia. The music is described as drawing from “all the Mongol tribes that Genghis Khan unified.” The group considers itself music gatherers whose goal is to preserve traditional sounds of Mongolia. Biligbaatar grew up among traditional herders who live in yurts. Additional photos are on the back page of this week’s Observer.
  • Front.bear
    HOLDEN HUTCHISON gives a hug to a black bear cub—the product of a taxidermist’s skills—at the Michigan DNR’s Great Youth Jamboree. The event on Sunday marked the fourth year of the Jamboree. Additional photos are on page 12.

Weekly newspaper serving SE Michigan and NW Ohio - State Line Observer ©2006-2016