Clearing the drains: Aiming to improve flow

Written by David Green.

By DAVID GREEN 

When the banks of ditches and small streams become overgrown with trees and shrubs, and small islands appear in the meandering channel, the usual response is to bring out the heavy equipment and clear the banks down to the soil and do some dredging.

That’s the typical course of action in many Michigan counties, but it isn’t the case everywhere.

In some locales, stream restoration projects are initiated—methods that handle flow problems without dredging and denuding the banks. It’s a matter of understanding how rivers function and allowing the water to handle the corrective action—along with some assistance from engineers.

crekk-clean-vertical A typical drain cleaning project calls for the removal of all plant growth on the stream bank, explained David Mitchell, an engineer with the Lenawee County Drain Commission. Minor dredging might be tackled to remove a sandbar, but since drain maintenance is limited to an expenditure of $2,500 a mile, dredging and bank reshaping is not part of routine maintenance.

Expenditures are held in check because costs are shared by everyone in the drain watershed—whether or not they had an interest drain cleaning.

As an example, Mitchell said, the cost of work underway on Silver Creek at Ridgeville Road, will be shared by property owners from Morenci up to Brown Road where that drain district begins. In total, 845 parcels are included.

A property owner often makes a request for drain cleaning, but in this case the drain superintendent identified the need while driving through the area.

The cost of the Silver Creek project is not yet tabulated, but notices should be sent soon announced the size of the special assessment for each property owner involved.

“It’s a large district and the cost per parcel will not be very large,” Mitchell said.

Property owners within the city of Morenci who are assessed should expect a charge of about $5. The assessments will be added to winter tax bills.

A review is scheduled from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. April 13 to give property owners the opportunity to examine their assessment.

“If somebody feels their apportionment is not fair, they have 10 days to appeal in court,” Mitchell said.

If the cost of a proposed project exceeds the maximum allowed for maintenance, the person making the request must file a petition for the work by collecting the names of five other people within the district.

The reason for drain cleaning is to improve the work of the drain or creek.

“We want to get the water flowing out of there,” he said.

Trees and brush on the banks collect other debris in the creek and work to slow the flow, Mitchell explained.

Farmers will sometimes request work to help their field tile outlets operate efficiently. Tile outlets buried under silt prevent drainage.

Once the banks are cleared and sprayed with an herbicide, vegetation is allowed to return on its own. Seeding of grass takes place only if banks are reshaped and expanses of soil are exposed.

Alternative

George Palmiter, a pioneer of restoration techniques developed in the 1970s, approaches a project with one goal in mind: Let the river do the work.

Palmiter worked as a railroad switchman, but he was also an avid canoeist who spent a lot of his free time on rivers. He gained nationwide attention for his techniques designed to restore the hydraulic capacity of streams without resorting to channelization and removal of riparian (stream side vegetation).

Trees are left in place—and some are even planted—for three reasons. Trees provide shade that reduce the growth of aquatic plants that tend to retard water flow. Shade also lowers water temperature in the summer, to the benefit of aquatic animals. Trees also anchor the bank, and the leaf litter provides a food source for aquatic life.

Palmiter removes logjams, or in many cases, cuts out the center and allows the buried ends to deflect water to the center of the stream. Eroded banks are often stabilized with logs, bundles of brush and planting of vegetation.

Bank corrections are made by removing selected trees and shrubs where the stream is too narrow. If the stream is too wide, current deflectors are created with natural material. This allows the river to clear out sand bars on its own. This also changes the flow characteristic in problem areas, such as severe bank erosion.

Palmiter’s changes mimic natural processes, allowing silt and sediment to wash out of the stream channel and end up in flood plains or in slow flowing stretches of the stream.

Palmiter was lauded by the U.S. Corps of for emphasizing the importance of shade along waterways. Without shade, Palmiter found, streams fill up with weedy, sun-loving aquatic plants that contribute to slowing water flow. Over time, an open stream will require more human intervention.

Removing all plants also destroys the habitat supporting aquatic life, along with the natural beauty of the steam.

Mitchell said he was not aware of Palmiter’s methodology.

Comparison

In 2000, a comparison between the usual clearing and dredging method and restoration techniques on Mill Creek in Michigan’s St. Clair County.

A study showed an increase in the water flow rate in the restoration areas after Palmiter’s techniques were put into action.

In the dredged areas, sediment began collecting in the creek bed as soon as four months after the work was completed. Algae and weeds were returning to the dredged sites within five months.

Support for aquatic life was rated excellent only at the sites that were never dredged, and the rating remained excellent after intervention using the restoration methods.

The quality of the habitat ranked lower after dredging.

Subsequent studies indicated continuing river health in the portion of the river that wasn’t dredged.

- March 17,2004 
  • Front.pokemon
    LATEST CRAZE—David Cortes (left) and Ty Kruse, along with Jerred Heselschwerdt (standing), consult their smartphones while engaging in the game of Pokémon Go. The virtual scavenger hunt comes to life when players are in the vicinity of gyms, such as Stair District Library, and PokéStops such as the fire station across the street. The boys had spent time Monday morning searching for Pokémon at Wakefield Park.
  • Front.drum
    on your mark, get set, drum!—Drew Joughin (black shirt), Maddox Joughin and Kaleea Braun took the front row last week when Angela Rettle and assistants led the Stair District Library Summer Reading Program kids in a session of cardio drumming. The sports and healthy living theme continued yesterday with a Mini Jamboree at Lake Hudson State Park arranged by the Michigan Department of Natural Resources. Next week’s program features the Flying Aces Frisbee show.
  • Girls.on.ride
    NADIYA YORK and Aniston Valentine take a spin on the Casino, one of the rides offered at Wakefield Park during Morenci’s Town and Country Festival. This year’s festival remained dry but with plenty of heat during the three-day run. Additional photographs are inside this week’s Observer.
  • Front.softball
    Angela Davis (2) and teammate Allison VanBrandt break into a jig after Morenci's softball team won its third consecutive regional title.
  • Front.art.park
    ART PARK—A design created by Poggemeyer Design Group shows a “pocket art park” in the green space south of the State Line Observer building. The proposal includes a 12-foot sculpture based on a design created by Morenci sixth grade student Klara Wesley through a school and library collaboration. A wooden band shell is located at the back of the lot. The Observer wall would be covered with a synthetic stucco material. City council members are considering ways to fund the estimated $125,000 project and perhaps tackling construction one step at a time.
  • Front.train
    WRECKAGE—Morenci Fire Department member Taylor Schisler walks past the smoking wreckage of a semi-truck tractor on the north side of the Norfolk and Southern Railroad tracks on Ranger Highway. The truck trailer was on the south side of the tracks
  • Funcolor
    LEONIE LEAHY was one of three local hair stylists who volunteered time Friday at the Morenci PTO Fun Night. Her customer, Aubrey Sandusky, looks up at her mother while her hair takes on a perfect match to her outfit. Leahy said she had a great time at the event—nothing but happy clients.
  • KayseInField
    IN THE FIELD—2004 Morenci graduate Kayse Onweller works in a test plot of wheat in Texas. She’s part of Bayer CropScience’s North American wheat breeding program based in Nebraska, where she completed post-graduate work in plant breeding and genetics.
  • Front.soccer.balls
    BEVY OF BALLS—Stair District Library Summer Reading Program VolunTeens, including Libby Rorick, back left and Ty Kruse, back right, threw a dozen inflatable soccer balls into the crowd during a reading of “Sergio Saves the Game.” The sports-themed program continues on Wednesdays through July 27.
  • Front.art.park
  • Front.drum
  • Shadow.salon

Weekly newspaper serving SE Michigan and NW Ohio - State Line Observer ©2006-2016